Kolkata, 29 Jul 2019 14:12 IST
The film is so monotonous and filled with repetitive dialogues that you can guess any part of the storyline even if you have missed 15 to 20 mins of it.
Mainak Bhaumik has attempted to incorporate a lot of elements in his crime drama Bornoporichoy but has left out the thrilling element entirely. The film follows a linear plot and doesn’t generate anticipation even for a single moment.
Bhaumik's 'innovative' concept of inserting complexities falls flat. He has taken a lot of references from Indian, and more specifically, Bengali philosophical texts and literature to add different dimensions to the crimes committed in the film. However, he hardly allows the time and scope for the audience to delve into those dimensions and enjoy the experience. Also, the references do not really lend complexities because they are not presented in the film as difficult riddles. They are solved quite easily, in a linear development. Thus, the climax doesn’t come across as surprising.
Bornoporichoy revolves around a chase game between a murderer (Abir Chatterjee) and police officer Dhananjay (Jisshu Sengupta). The mysterious series of crimes take away all from Dhananjay’s life, including his wife Malini (Priyanka Sarkar) and son Gogol. The murderer keeps puzzling him, with his apparently unpredictable methods. In a maddening chase, Dhananjay fails to prioritise his relationships and hence, Malini leaves with their son.
The shrewd murderer takes a gap of two years after committing five murders in a cold-blooded manner. As he returns, he begins to follow the pattern of Pancha Mahabhut, referring to the five primary elements – fire, earth, water, air and sky, while choosing the location and the method of killing more victims and intentionally leaves certain clues for the police. Dhananjay, on the other hand, plunges into deep depression, after separation with his family and quits his job. He drowns himself in alcohol and keeps meddling with all the evidences left behind by the murderer.
He goes to visit his son on his birthday, drunk, and therefore, his wife doesn’t allow him to meet Gogol. Dejected, Dhananjay again drowns himself in alcohol until his mother-in-law shows up the next morning and urges him to get back to handling his case so that he can find peace.
The rest of the plot narrates how Dhananjay unravels the case. Strangely, what seemed to be the most puzzling case for him, suddenly turns quite easy for him to unravel, after he dons his police avatar again. Before he returns to the case, he says the murderer has committed all the murders without leaving any clue. However, in drunken state, he is often seen to be immersing into the evidences left behind. Nevertheless, post intermission, leaving one instance, he begins to win in almost every stage of the case that once took away so much of his attention that he forgot all his responsibilities towards his family.
The murderer is attributed with certain psychotic traits which allow him to commit crimes in cold blood. While committing the crimes, he refers to his favourite lines from poems or philosophical texts to justify his acts in a broader sense. The mystery lies in his continuous references, which eventually explain his motive behind getting into such heinous acts.
The director has also taken help of the classic trope of creating an uncanny bond between the murderer and the police officer, inherent in many detective and thriller stories and films, which leads to a predictable ending.
Abir Chatterjee could have been much more dramatic in his avatar of a psychopathic criminal. His monotonous act hardly brings the dangerous traits of his character. In the brief moments of vulnerability, his performance is extremely one dimensional. Also, Bhaumik could have infused more depth in delineating the character, that has turned into a psychopathic murderer because of some personal loss. Had there been more agony instead of smartness in his traits, perhaps, his character could have had more impact.
Jisshu Sengupta delivers an average act as the drunk police officer, who suddenly turns out to be extremely suave and smart while solving the crimes. His act during his moments of helplessness do not produce much impact.
Priyanka Sarkar seems to be in a hurry while delivering her dialogues.
Writer Anwoy Mukherjee has penned some heavy dialogues for the characters. While speaking, the characters promise to come up with a lot of challenges and twists, which the narrative doesn’t justify. Also, some of his dialogues lose coherence as the plot progresses, creating confusions.
Director of photography Ramyadip Saha and editor Sanglap Bhowmik adopted a stylised cinematic approach, that could have been fit for a richer content. Both the technicians had a lot more to offer but were not given the opportunities.
Composer Indradeep Dasgupta’s lead guitar-based background score appears extremely monotonous throughout the film. Anupam Roy’s composition 'Bishonno Chimney' is a well written song, rendered by Arijit Singh. It goes well with the gloomy mood of the separated couple who yearn to get together.
Bornoporichoy is a huge let-down in terms of its content. The film is so monotonous and filled with repetitive dialogues that you can guess any part of the storyline even if you have missed 15 to 20 mins of it. Also, Bhaumik could have put more efforts in dramatizing the equation between the chased and the chaser, which could have turned into the USP of the film and made it more engaging. Also, the film is quite short in length and gives away the feeling that the director could not think of many more elements or twists to incorporate before the climax.
Related topicsMovie Review
You might also like
Midnight Mirror review: Preys on legitimate fears of women traveling alone at night
Directed by Debanjan Majhi, this short film featuring Trina Saha, Sharonyo Banerjee and Apratim an...
Mangsho - The Meat review: Bold and disturbing picture of politics during the lockdown
The film is driven by powerful and spontaneous performances by the artistes....
Ekti Tara review: Interesting concept that's needlessly prolonged by the dialogues
This lockdown short by Shieladitya Moulik is somewhat redeemed by the twist at the end. ...